The Indianapolis Colts have been plagued by a disturbing trend in recent years, one that has left fans frustrated and searching for answers. The team’s inability to win meaningful late-season games, often against mediocre quarterbacks, has become a norm that is both concerning and alarming. This trend is not an anomaly, but rather a persistent pattern that has defined the Colts’ performance in critical situations.
A Look Back at Recent History
The Colts’ struggles in big games date back to 2021, when they lost a Week 17 game to the 2-win Jacksonville Jaguars, effectively ending their playoff hopes. This defeat was not an isolated incident, as the Colts have continued to struggle in similar situations. In 2023, they lost crucial December games to backup quarterbacks Jake Browning and Taylor Heinicke, ultimately falling one game short of the playoffs.
The most recent example of this trend was the Colts’ humiliating loss to the 2-win New York Giants, who were led by backup quarterback Drew Lock. This defeat was particularly galling, as the Colts allowed 45 points and lost by 12 points in a game they desperately needed to win.
Chris Ballard’s Candid Admission
When asked about the Colts’ struggles in big games, General Manager Chris Ballard offered a candid and introspective response. Ballard acknowledged that the team’s inability to win these games was a concern and pointed to the absence of players like Andrew Luck and Philip Rivers, who had previously led the team to victory in similar situations.
However, Ballard also hinted at a deeper issue, one that goes beyond the presence or absence of individual players. He suggested that the Colts lack “tough guys” who can battle through adversity and emerge victorious in critical situations.
The Implication of Ballard’s Comments
Ballard’s reference to “tough guys” is a telling one, as it implies that the Colts’ roster lacks the mental and physical toughness needed to succeed in big games. This is a damning indictment of the team’s personnel, and one that reflects poorly on Ballard’s own performance as General Manager.
After all, Ballard has been responsible for constructing the Colts’ roster for the past eight years. His inability to assemble a team that can win big games is a clear failing, one that raises questions about his future with the organization.
A Call to Action
As the Colts look to the future, it is clear that they need to address their lack of “tough guys” who can perform under pressure. This will require a concerted effort from Ballard and the rest of the front office, as well as a renewed focus on building a roster that is capable of succeeding in big games.
Ultimately, the Colts’ ability to win championships will depend on their ability to identify and acquire players who possess the mental and physical toughness needed to succeed at the highest level. Until they can do so, they will continue to struggle in big games, and their fans will be left to wonder what might have been.
