The Buffalo Bills are facing another tough break with Matt Milano sidelined due to a torn bicep. Milano’s injury and the expected long recovery time mean the Bills’ defense will have to adjust yet again, as this is becoming a recurring theme for the team. This season, they’ll need to rely on someone else to step up, and Dorian Williams, a second-year player from Tulane, is the likely candidate to fill in. Williams had some experience last year when Milano was out, playing alongside Terrel Bernard. While Williams is expected to start, it’s a big step up from a rotational role, and it’s uncertain if he can maintain Milano’s level of play until Milano returns, whether this season or the next.

However, relying solely on internal options might not be enough. There are other potential solutions available, and the Bills should consider exploring these options to strengthen their linebacker corps. Let’s look at some of the players who could potentially help the Bills in this situation:

Shaquille Leonard

Formerly known as Darius Leonard, Shaquille Leonard is a player with a notable track record. He was the 2018 Defensive Rookie of the Year and has been a dominant force in the league. Leonard has been a First-Team All-Pro in three of his first four seasons and led the NFL in tackles as a rookie. At one point, he was the highest-paid outside linebacker in NFL history. However, Leonard’s career has been plagued by injuries in recent years. He has struggled with multiple injuries that have affected his performance, leading to frustrations about his playing time. The Indianapolis Colts released him, and although he was briefly picked up by the Philadelphia Eagles, he didn’t perform well and remains unsigned.

If Leonard is willing to sign for a reasonable price, he could be a high-reward addition. There’s a chance he could return to his previous form in 2024, but there’s also a risk. If his performance doesn’t improve, it could negatively impact the team. Leonard is an option with potential but comes with uncertainty.

A.J. Klein

A.J. Klein recently announced his retirement, but if he hasn’t fully retired yet, he could be a potential option for the Bills. Klein was called upon by the Bills late last season when injuries hit the team hard. While he’s not a top-tier player, his familiarity with the team and its defensive system makes him a practical choice. Klein might not raise the team’s ceiling significantly, but he could help stabilize the linebacker position and provide much-needed depth.

Zach Cunningham

Zach Cunningham is another veteran who could be a valuable addition. Cunningham had notable early success with the Houston Texans alongside J.J. Watt. While he’s not as well-known as Leonard, Cunningham had a solid season in 2023. The main concern with Cunningham is his health, as he has dealt with injuries in the past couple of seasons. If he’s able to stay healthy, Cunningham could be a good fit, either as a starter or a rotational player. However, he’s likely looking for a long-term deal, which may not align with the Bills’ plans.

Kwon Alexander

Kwon Alexander is coming off a significant injury, a ruptured Achilles, which ended his previous season. If he has fully recovered, Alexander could be an option. While his best years might be behind him, he’s an experienced player who could provide depth and a few impactful plays. He would likely be available for a low cost, making him an acceptable choice for the Bills if they’re looking to add a veteran presence to their young linebacker group.

Trade Option: Jamin Davis

Finally, there’s the possibility of trading for Jamin Davis from the Washington Commanders. Davis has had a solid career with 269 tackles, seven sacks, and an interception in three seasons. He’s a physical player who could compete for a starting role or provide solid depth.

Davis’s situation is unique because he’s not currently a starter for Washington, who have Bobby Wagner and Frankie Luvu in the lineup. With Davis entering the final year of his rookie contract and his fifth-year option declined, his trade value is relatively low, potentially making him an affordable option. However, Davis has had off-field issues, including a conviction for reckless driving. Although he avoided jail time, this has affected his market value.

For the Bills, acquiring Davis could be a strategic move. It allows them to address their immediate needs at linebacker while providing Davis with an opportunity to prove himself. This could benefit both parties—Davis gets a chance to compete for a new contract, and the Bills get a player who can contribute without a long-term commitment.

The Buffalo Bills need to make a decision on how to address their linebacker situation in the wake of Matt Milano’s injury. They have several options to consider, from free agents like Shaquille Leonard and Kwon Alexander to possible trade targets like Jamin Davis. Each option comes with its own set of risks and benefits.

Leonard offers high potential but also comes with uncertainty due to his recent injury struggles. Klein, while not an elite player, provides stability and familiarity with the team. Cunningham could be a solid pickup if he stays healthy, and Alexander could offer veteran depth at a low cost. Trading for Davis might be the best long-term solution, giving the Bills a chance to address their immediate needs while managing their salary cap effectively.