The debate is heating up among Browns fans about Deshaun Watson’s elite status as a quarterback. While Watson himself believes he can regain his elite form, citing his hard work and preparation ¹, many fans and analysts are skeptical. His performance since joining the Browns has been underwhelming, with a QBR of 41.9, ranking sixth-lowest in the NFL ¹.
Some argue that Watson’s inconsistency and inability to stay healthy are major concerns. In 2022, he completed a career-low 58.2% of his passes, throwing for 1,102 yards, 7 touchdowns, and 5 interceptions in just six games ¹. Others point out that the Browns’ success last season, with a solid 11-6 record and a wild-card berth, was despite Watson’s limited participation ¹.
Critics, like Randy Gurzi, are calling for Watson to be benched, citing his poor performance and the team’s need to move on ². They argue that Watson’s struggles with holding onto the ball, missing open players, and prone to turnovers are too significant to overlook. Gurzi suggests that Jameis Winston, although not elite, might be a better option for the team ².
However, Watson’s confidence and past performances with the Texans offer a glimmer of hope. Fans still holding onto the hope that Watson can regain his 2020 form, where he showed exceptional skill, are eager to see him prove himself this season ².
Ultimately, the jury is still out on Watson’s elite status, and only time will tell if he can silence his critics and lead the Browns to success.
